Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing

Safety & Inspections

Health deficiencies

National median: 7

24 above national median

Total federal penalties

$51,776

CMS data as of January 1, 2026

Staffing breakdown

Average hours of nursing care each resident receives per day, by staff role. Higher numbers generally indicate more attentive care.

Total nurse staffing

National median: 4.12 hrs

3.41 hrs below national median

Registered nurse (RN)

0.83 hrs

Licensed practical nurse (LPN)

0.79 hrs

Certified nursing aide (CNA)

1.97 hrs

Physical therapy

0.00 hrs

Quality rating trend

Overall rating declined from 2 to 1 stars over 18 data points.

Facility profile

Type

Skilled Nursing Facility · Nursing home

Capacity

71 certified beds · ~56 avg residents/day (79% occupancy)

Ownership

For profit - Limited Liability company

Payment accepted

Medicare Medicaid (Medicare and Medicaid)

About

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing is a 71-bed, for-profit facility organized as a limited liability company in Evansville, Wisconsin. The center currently holds a 1-star overall rating from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), based on a 1-star health inspection rating and a 2-star staffing rating. While the facility received 3 stars for quality measures, it is subject to federal oversight through the CMS Special Focus Facility program.

Location

470 Garfield Ave, Evansville, 53536, Evansville, WI

Recent reviews

• Don Behling ★★★★★ December 12, 2025

  Fantastic staff! Everyone was very caring and helpful. The rehab services were excellent.

• Helen Christison ★★★★☆ October 5, 2025

  This is a great place. I am at a different place now and it is nothing like evansville. I would tell anyone to see. L am sorry they would not send me there this time.

• Nicole M ★☆☆☆☆ June 27, 2025

  NO STARS! DO NOT TAKE YOUR LOVED ONES HERE!!!!!<br>Evansville Manor neglected my mom. They made her eat cold, raw, pureed food. I was told Mark made her eat it. When she was in the hospital after, she ate all sorts of food and never choked once.<br>One of their aids left my mom in a wheelchair for 10 hours unattended, soiled herself, and the aid only got suspended and still works there. The employees fall asleep on the job, fall asleep on residents that do need help getting fed, and sit on their phones. When you visit, anyone could just walk in, no one is at the desk to help, and residents are scattered there unattended. These residents pay money to be taken care of, and no one there seems to care for their well-being.<br>When my mom got sick, she was having breathing problems and needed an emergency inhaler. The medicine employee, Shay brought her rescue inhaler, and just teased her, waving it in front of her face, refusing to give it to her. Is this how your employees treat their patients? The nurses are mean, then why are they working? Getting mad at her for "having to clean" her, "having to dress" her.<br>Most importantly, my mom complained of abdominal pain for MONTHS there, and all the nurses dismissed it as "just muscle". When she got sick and was taken to St. Mary's hospital by ambulance, to find out that "muscle"  she complained about was actually ascites of the liver. Why did your employees ignore her? She died from cirrhosis of the liver that could have been possibly caught in time before it killed her. She got 12 liters of fluid removed from her that could have been drained before it got that bad. The fluid build up got so bad and ignored that it made her kidneys get so bad, she was denied dialysis. The fluid got so bad, half her heart stopped working. The fluid buildup got so bad, it caused her to have a hard time breathing. the fluid got so bad, FOUR of her organs failed. This all could have saved her if she wasn't ignored and got help before it was too late. She was supposed to get released from your nursing home, but instead we have a grieving family.<br>I demand answers on why your company, the place my family trusted you to take care of our loved one, ignored and neglected our now dead mother?<br>If you're looking for a facility to take your loved one, I suggest finding somewhere else.

• Mary Triggs ★★★★☆ June 24, 2025

  I felt very care for while I stayed in rehab,unfortunately my illness is tricky and my care is needing more help from specialist at this time. I would recommend people to use this place for easy rehabilitation needs. A huge Thank you to the aides and nurses that took care of me, and PT & OT. I was walking when they started and something changed and they still worked with what I had to use!!<br>Thanks to you all!!<br>Mary

• Belva Kramer ★★★★★ April 15, 2025

  In a time where it is hard to staff a business like EVM, they do quite well. My son spent a month in a hospital with NO diagnosis and EVM's staff figured out his problem. That tells me he has people that THINK about him and what his problem might be. I'm thankful the system sent him to EVM for rehab and he was OK with staying because I am to old to care for him anymore. They must be doing something right.

Frequently asked questions

What is the overall CMS rating for Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing?

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing has an overall CMS rating of 1 out of 5 stars.

How did Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing score on health inspections?

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing received a health inspection rating of 1 out of 5 stars from CMS.

What is the staffing rating for Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing?

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing has a staffing rating of 2 out of 5 stars, based on nurse-to-resident ratios.

How many beds does Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing have?

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing has 71 certified beds.

Does Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing accept Medicare or Medicaid?

Yes, Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing accepts Medicare and Medicaid.

Where is Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing located?

Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing is located at 470 Garfield Ave, Evansville, 53536, Evansville, Wisconsin.

How can I contact Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing?

You can reach Evansville Manor Skilled Nursing by phone at +1 608-882-5700.

More facilities in Wisconsin

No facilities listed within the immediate area. Here are highly rated options elsewhere in Wisconsin.

• Rolling Hills Rehab Ctr Sparta · 5.0★

  14400 Cty Hwy B, Sparta, WI, 54656

• Lafayette Manor Darlington · 5.0★

  719 E Catherine St Box 167, Darlington, WI, 53530

• Edenbrook Platteville Platteville · 4.9★

  1300 N Water St, Platteville, 53818

• Careview of Minocqua Minocqua · 4.9★

  9969 Old Hwy 70, Minocqua, 54548

• Brewster Village Appleton · 4.9★

  3300 W Brewster St, Appleton, 54914